Skip to content
Get a fee quote
Business·US UK Tax Hub Tax Team

Three weeks in Texas, and a form nobody mentioned

An empty canal lock at dawn, its timber gates closed, illustrating Form 8233 for UK contractors on US sites
A British freelancer who works on site in America earns US-source pay. The client withholds 30% unless a Form 8233, with a US tax number on it, arrives first.

A British freelancer booked for a site job in America keeps the full fee only if a treaty claim reaches the client before the first invoice. That claim is Form 8233 for UK contractors, and it needs a US tax number that can take weeks to obtain.

Most freelancers learn this the wrong way round. They fly out, do the job, invoice, and find 30% missing.

Nothing went wrong with the work. The ITIN application simply started too late, or never started at all.

So this guide covers which treaty article a sole trader relies on, what the tax number involves, and what the client must do with the form. Then it covers how the calendar catches people out.

Why does a site visit make the fee American?

Because the work happened in America. Publication 515 requires 30% withholding on pay to a nonresident alien for personal services performed in the United States. That rule applies regardless of where the parties signed the contract or where the money goes. So the site address drives everything.

A Leeds bank account changes nothing. Neither does a sterling invoice or a contract under English law.

That 30% comes off the gross fee, not the profit. On a job with flights, hotels and equipment hire to cover, it can exceed the margin.

In our practice the first call usually comes after the fee lands short. By then the tax has gone to the IRS, and the client cannot simply hand it back.

What is Form 8233?

Form 8233 is the certificate a nonresident alien individual gives a US payer to claim treaty exemption from withholding. It covers some or all of their pay for personal services, whether self-employed or employed. It goes to the payer first, not straight to the IRS.

The Form 8233 instructions describe independent personal services as work a self-employed contractor does in the US. Consulting fees and contract labour both fall inside that description.

So an on-site engineer, trainer or installer billing as a sole trader is exactly who the form serves.

Which treaty article does a sole trader rely on?

Article 7, on business profits. The UK-US treaty has no separate article for independent personal services. Article 3 defines business to include professional services and other independent activities. Article 7 then taxes those profits only in the UK, unless they arise through a US permanent establishment.

The Form 8233 instructions confirm the route. Certain treaties lack an independent personal services article, and the business profits article may then cover that pay.

So the question for a sole trader is not how many days you spend in America. It is whether you have a permanent establishment there.

Article 5 defines that as a fixed place of business through which the business operates. A building site or installation project counts only if it lasts more than twelve months.

Self-employed (sole trader)Employee
Treaty articleArticle 7, business profitsArticle 14, income from employment
What decides the exemptionNo US permanent establishmentAll three Article 14(2) conditions
Day countNot the test itselfNot over 183 days in any twelve-month period starting or ending in the year
Form if claiming exemptionForm 8233Form 8233
Form if not claimingNone, so 30% appliesForm W-4, graduated withholding

Why won't a W-8BEN do?

Because its own instructions exclude this case. The W-8BEN instructions tell a nonresident alien individual not to use it to claim exemption on pay for personal services performed in the US. They point to Form 8233 or Form W-4 instead. That covers both independent and dependent services.

That is the single most common error we see. The client's portal sends a W-8BEN to every foreign supplier. The freelancer signs it, and nobody checks where the work will happen.

A W-8BEN still has a job to do. It documents that you are not a US person, which matters for work you do from Britain.

Which means the right form depends on one fact: where you will stand while you work.

What changes if you are an employee?

The article changes, and the conditions tighten. Article 14 exempts UK employment income earned in America only if three things hold. You spend no more than 183 days there in the relevant twelve-month period. Your employer is not a US resident, and no US permanent establishment of the employer bears the pay.

All three must hold together. So a UK resident hired straight onto a US company's payroll fails the employer condition, however short the visit.

Pay that does not qualify runs through Form W-4 and graduated withholding instead. That is the same wage system Americans use.

Our guide to working for a US employer with no UK payroll covers the employed version from the other direction.

Do you need a US tax number?

Yes, and this is where the timetable usually breaks. The instructions require a US taxpayer identification number on the form, which usually means a social security number. Anyone without one, and unable to get one, must apply for an individual taxpayer identification number on Form W-7.

Most British freelancers have neither, so the ITIN route applies.

Where the ITIN is needed for a Form 8233 claim, file Form W-7 with the required documents now. The instructions do not make you wait for a tax return.

And if you have applied but have no number yet, you can attach a copy of the completed W-7. That keeps the claim moving while the IRS works.

What does the client do with the form?

The client reviews it, decides whether the exemption looks warranted, and signs the acceptance in Part IV. Within 5 days of accepting, it must forward a copy to the IRS. It then waits at least 10 days after mailing to see whether the IRS objects, while the exemption still reaches back to the first covered payment.

But the client must refuse the form if it knows, or has reason to know, that a statement on it may be false.

It must also refuse where your eligibility cannot readily be determined. A known US permanent establishment is the example the instructions give.

If the IRS later says your eligibility is in doubt, the client must start withholding immediately. So a vague description of the work invites trouble.

How long does the form last?

One tax year. The instructions require a separate Form 8233 for each tax year, with the year stated above Part I. You also need a separate form for each withholding agent and each type of income. So a job running from November into January needs two forms, one per year.

That catches repeat visitors, since last year's form does nothing for this year's job.

So diarise the renewal, just as you would for the company version, but on a much shorter cycle.

What if the work is done from the UK?

What if the work is done from the UK? — Form 8233 for UK contractors
From our guide to Form 8233 for UK contractors on US sites.

Then none of this applies to that work. Pub 515 states that pay to a nonresident alien for services performed outside the United States is not wages. It is not subject to withholding either. Work you do at a desk in Leeds is foreign-source income for American purposes.

The client will still want proof that you are foreign, which is the W-8BEN's job. Our article on the W-8BEN-E for a UK company covers the entity version.

Mixed contracts need an allocation. Pub 515 generally splits that pay on a time basis, by days worked in each country.

Our guide to remote work for a US employer covers the arrangement where nobody travels.

Who cannot use the treaty exemption?

Anyone who is not a nonresident alien. A US citizen living in Leeds cannot claim this exemption. The treaty's saving clause lets America tax its own citizens as if the treaty had not come into effect. Green card holders face a similar problem, because they are US residents rather than nonresident aliens.

The instructions also say you must be a resident of the treaty country to claim either article.

Performers sit apart too. Their own article takes precedence, and our guide to US withholding on UK performers covers it.

Then there is the fixed base point. A contractor with a US office or fixed base available generally cannot claim the exemption.

Does an exemption mean no US return?

Not necessarily. Publication 519 says that performing personal services in the US usually means you are engaged in a US trade or business. A nonresident alien in that position must file Form 1040-NR, subject to limited exceptions, even where the income is exempt from tax.

Exemption from withholding and freedom from filing are two different things.

A treaty disclosure is a separate question again, and our note on Form 8833 sets out when it arises.

Our US federal returns service prepares the 1040-NR alongside the form, so the facts on both match.

What if 30% has already been withheld?

Then recovery runs through the IRS, not the client. Pub 515 notes that payers often must withhold because treaty eligibility stays unclear until the year ends. The contractor then files Form 1040-NR to recover any overwithheld tax, with proof of entitlement to the treaty exemption.

The client reports the payment and the tax on Form 1042-S, which becomes your evidence.

So ask for that statement early. Without it the refund claim has nothing behind it.

In our practice the refund itself is rarely the problem. The months without the cash are.

An illustrative example

Take a Leeds-based freelance AV engineer, trading as a sole trader. She is booked for three weeks on site in Texas to commission a conference centre's sound and video system.

She does the work in the US, so the fee is US-source. She has no US office, and a three-week installation sits far below Article 5's twelve-month threshold.

She files Form W-7 for an ITIN and attaches a copy to her Form 8233, citing the treaty and Article 7. The client accepts it, posts a copy to the IRS within 5 days, and pays in full.

These facts are illustrative. Change one, such as a desk in the client's Dallas office kept for her all year, and the permanent establishment question needs real work.

Completing Form 8233 for UK contractors, step by step

Form 8233 for UK contractors works best as a pre-travel task, not a post-invoice one. Start once the client confirms the booking.

The ITIN is the part that needs lead time.

  1. Confirm whether you are invoicing as a sole trader or being paid as an employee.
  2. Check that no US office or fixed base is available to you during the job.
  3. Apply for an ITIN on Form W-7 if you have no SSN, and keep a copy.
  4. Complete Form 8233 for the tax year of the work, naming the treaty and article.
  5. Describe the services and estimate the year's total fee from this client.
  6. Give it to the client before the first payment, and ask them to confirm acceptance.

Common mistakes we see

The first is signing a W-8BEN for on-site work because the portal asked for one.

The second is leaving the ITIN until after the trip, when the first payment has already gone out short.

The third is reusing last year's form. It covers one tax year and one client, nothing more.

A fourth is treating Form 8233 for UK contractors as the end of the matter. A 1040-NR may still be due.

How US UK Tax Hub helps with on-site US work

We settle the treaty article first, because a sole trader and an employee need different claims. Our double tax treaty relief service answers the permanent establishment question before anybody signs.

Then we handle the ITIN, Form 8233 for UK contractors and the client's questions in one sequence. That way the paperwork is ready before the flight.

If the client has sent a W-8BEN for a US booking, talk to us before you sign it.

Last reviewed . Tax thresholds and rates change annually — check the figures against the current tax year.

Questions this raises for readers

Not for this. The W-8BEN instructions tell a nonresident alien individual not to use it to claim exemption from withholding on pay for personal services performed in the US, and to provide Form 8233 or Form W-4 instead. A W-8BEN still documents foreign status for work done from the UK.


Article 7, on business profits. The treaty has no separate independent personal services article, and Article 3 defines business to include professional services and other independent activities. The profits stay taxable only in the UK unless they arise through a US permanent establishment, so that is the question to answer first.


You need a US taxpayer identification number, which is usually an SSN. If you have none and cannot get one, you apply for an ITIN on Form W-7 with the required documents. Where you have applied but have no number yet, a copy of the completed W-7 can go with the form.


The client reviews and accepts it, then forwards a copy to the IRS within 5 days of acceptance. It must wait at least 10 days after mailing to see whether the IRS objects. The exemption still runs back to the first payment the form covers, so early submission matters more than speed.


No. The instructions require a separate form for each tax year, with the year written above Part I. You also need a separate form for each withholding agent and each type of income, so a repeat client or a second client in the same year both mean fresh paperwork.


Not as the test itself. The 183-day condition sits in Article 14, which covers employment. A sole trader relies on Article 7, where the question is whether the business has a US permanent establishment. Time on site still matters to that analysis, but it is not a simple day count.


No. The form is for nonresident alien individuals, and the treaty's saving clause lets America tax its own citizens as if the treaty had not come into effect. A US citizen in Britain reports worldwide income on Form 1040 and relies on credits and exclusions instead.

Booked for a job on a US site?

This article is general information, not personal tax advice. Send us the booking and whatever forms the client has asked for, and we will set out the right claim before you travel.

Get a fee quote