
A founder who dies owning a trading company usually leaves a far smaller inheritance tax bill than the balance sheet suggests. Business property relief is the reason, and it has been part of the furniture for decades.
So the planning conversation in Britain tends to be short. The company qualifies, the relief applies, and the family keeps the business rather than selling it to pay a tax bill.
An American founder sitting in the same chair gets a different answer, because the US estate tax runs alongside the British one. It reaches a citizen's worldwide estate wherever they lived.
In our practice this surfaces late, usually when somebody is writing a will rather than when they are building the company. By then the shares are worth a great deal more.
The relief is still worth having. It simply does less than the family thinks it does.
What is business property relief?
Business property relief reduces the value of qualifying business assets for inheritance tax, either by 100% or by 50%. The GOV.UK guidance sets out which assets fall into which rate, and the conditions attached to each.
It exists so that a family does not have to break up a working business to pay a tax bill when its owner dies.
What qualifies at each rate
The split matters more than it used to, because the 100% column now has a ceiling on it.
Land, buildings and machinery held personally rather than inside the company sit in the 50% row even where the business itself qualifies in full.
So two people with the same company can get very different answers, depending on who owns the premises.
| Asset | Rate |
|---|---|
| A business or an interest in a business | 100%, up to the allowance |
| Shares in an unlisted company | 100%, up to the allowance |
| Qualifying property above the allowance | 50% |
| Shares on a market HMRC does not treat as listed, such as AIM | 50% |
| Shares controlling over 50% of the votes in a listed company | 50% |
| Land, buildings or machinery used in a business the deceased controlled | 50% |
The cap that arrived in April 2026
For deaths on or after 6 April 2026, the 100% rate stops at £2.5 million of qualifying business or agricultural property. Anything above that line gets 50% instead.
The figure was not always going to be £2.5 million. The government raised the threshold from £1 million before the change took effect, and said the allowance would transfer between spouses.
Shares on markets that do not meet the definition of listed, AIM among them, now get 50% in every case.
So a founder with a £10 million company is looking at relief on part of it, not all of it.
The two-year rule
Ownership has to run for two full years before the death. That is the plainest condition in the whole relief and the easiest to fall foul of.
Restructuring, incorporating or swapping one holding for another can reset that clock without anybody noticing.
Assets not used mainly for business purposes in the two years before they passed also fall outside the relief.
So the date of a reorganisation is a tax fact, not just a corporate one.
Keep the paperwork for the whole period. Proving two years of ownership is easy while the founder is alive and awkward once they are not.
What does not qualify at all
Businesses dealing mainly in securities, stocks or shares, in land or buildings, or in making or holding investments. That last phrase does a great deal of work.
A property company is the common casualty. So is a company that has quietly accumulated cash and investments alongside a shrinking trade.
Not-for-profit organisations are outside the relief, as are businesses being wound up unless the winding up is part of carrying the business on.
So the trading status of the company is worth testing before anybody relies on the relief.
Our note on UK inheritance tax for Americans covers how the rest of the estate is treated alongside the company.
Why the US estate tax changes the answer
Because the US estate tax applies to the worldwide estate of a citizen, wherever they lived and wherever the assets sit. A UK company sits inside it.
That tax has no equivalent of business property relief. Nothing in it takes a trading company out of the taxable estate merely for trading.
So the British relief can reduce the inheritance tax to nothing while the US estate tax on the same shares stays exactly where it was.
The two systems are measuring the same company and reaching different answers on purpose.
How the US estate tax actually works
It starts from the whole estate and then allows a lifetime exclusion, rather than giving relief asset by asset. That structural difference is the heart of the problem here.
A trading company gets no better treatment than a portfolio of shares. Both are simply value in the estate.
The rate that applies above the exclusion is substantial, so the question is how much value sits above the line rather than what kind of value it is.
So the planning levers are different. You move value out of the estate, or you fund the charge, because you cannot relieve the asset.
An illustrative example
Take an American who has lived in Britain for thirty years and owns an engineering company worth £6 million. She dies in 2027, leaving the shares to her son.
On the British side, the first £2.5 million gets 100% relief and the balance gets 50%. The inheritance tax on the company is modest.
On the American side the full £6 million forms part of her worldwide estate, converted to dollars, with no relief for the fact that it is a trading business.
Her British business partner's family keeps the company. Hers may have to sell part of it to find the cash.
Valuing the shares is the whole argument
Every figure in this article depends on one number, and that number is a matter of opinion until somebody defends it.
A private company has no quoted price, so the valuation rests on earnings, on assets and on what a hypothetical buyer would pay for a minority stake.
Both tax authorities can look at it, and they will not necessarily look at it the same way.
So commission the valuation properly rather than treating it as a formality. It is the number the family will live with.
Does the credit not sort this out?
Only partly, and the gap is exactly the shape of the relief. A credit against the US estate tax relieves tax actually paid in the other country, and the whole effect of business property relief is that the estate pays less inheritance tax.
So the better the British relief works, the less there is to credit against the American charge. The family ends up paying the American tax in full on the relieved slice.
It is the same pattern that catches exemptions elsewhere in the system, arriving once rather than annually.
What the estate tax convention does
There is an estate and gift tax convention between the two countries, and it allocates taxing rights rather than cancelling one side's tax. The IRS treaty page lists the estate and gift conventions in force.
It can determine which country taxes which assets first, and it provides credit mechanisms. It does not import a British relief into American law.
Claiming under it is a filing exercise with its own disclosure, not something that happens automatically.
So treat the convention as part of the computation rather than as an answer to it.
A spouse who is not a US citizen
The usual rule that leaves everything to a surviving spouse without charge is narrower when that spouse is not an American citizen.
Where it does not apply, the estate can face the US estate tax on the first death rather than the second, which is exactly when the company is least liquid.
There is a trust route that preserves the deferral, and it has to be in place rather than improvised afterwards.
So a mixed-nationality marriage is a reason to look at the will early, not a detail to settle later.
Finding the cash for the American tax
An estate that is mostly a company has a cash problem as well as a tax problem. The Form 706 instructions carry the rules for paying part of the tax in instalments where a closely held business makes up more than 35% of the adjusted gross estate.
That route buys time rather than reducing the bill, and it comes with conditions that can accelerate the whole balance if the business is sold.
So it is a plan, not a cure. It still beats a forced sale.
- Value the company properly, because every later step depends on that number.
- Work out the share of the US estate tax attributable to the business interest.
- Check whether the business interest exceeds 35% of the adjusted gross estate, since that is the test for paying by instalments.
- Read the instalment rules in the Form 706 instructions before assuming the estate qualifies.
- Look at what else in the estate is liquid, and at what the company itself could distribute.
- Decide whether life cover held outside the estate is the cleaner answer.
- Write the decision into the will and tell the executors where the money is coming from.
Lifetime gifts are not a free escape
Giving shares away during life is the standard British answer, and it works on the British side if the donor survives long enough.
The American gift tax runs on different rules and does not follow the British seven-year clock. A lifetime gift can produce an American charge immediately.
A gift also has to be reported, and the reporting is separate from the tax.
So test a gift in both systems before making it, because it cannot be unwound afterwards.
What a cross-border will needs to do
It needs to say who gets the shares, and it needs to be read against two tax systems rather than one.
Drafting that works perfectly for inheritance tax can create an American problem, particularly where trusts are involved.
Our note on probate across two countries covers the administration that follows.
So get both views on the draft before anybody signs it, rather than after probate has started.
What the executors will need
A clear list of what the deceased owned, when they acquired it, and what the company does.
Then evidence that the business was trading rather than investing, because that is the question HMRC asks first.
On the American side they will need the same facts in dollars, plus a view on how the estate will fund the tax.
So assemble it while the founder can still explain the history. Nobody else remembers why the holding company was set up in 2009.
Trusts hold an allowance too
Trustees have their own allowance for the 100% rate, applied at the ten-year anniversary charges and at exit charges.
Where the same settlor has made several settlements, a cap applies across them rather than an allowance for each.
An American settlor or beneficiary brings a separate set of American trust rules on top of all that.
So a trust is a planning tool here and a reporting obligation there, and both have to be priced in.
Common mistakes we see
The first is assuming the British relief means the family owes nothing. It means HMRC asks for little, which is not the same thing.
The second is holding the trading premises personally without realising it drops that asset to the 50% rate.
The third is letting cash and investments build up inside the company until the trading status looks doubtful.
A fourth is writing a will that works beautifully in one country and creates a trust the other country taxes.
How we help with a family company
We start by testing whether the company qualifies at all, because everything else is academic if the trading status fails.
Then we model the two charges side by side, including what the estate would actually have to find in cash.
Our treaty relief work covers the convention and the credit position, and you can get in touch while the shares are still worth planning around.
So the useful time to look at this is years before anybody expects to need it.




