Skip to content
Get a fee quote
Cross-border·US UK Tax Hub Tax Team

Borrowing from your own company, twice taxed

Two clocks side by side on a dark wall, illustrating Section 956 and a UK director's loan
Taking money out of your company and squaring it later is normal here. An American shareholder has a rule waiting that most British accountants have never had to think about.

Taking money out of a company you own and tidying it up at the year end is ordinary British practice. The accountant records it as a director's loan, the company squares it, and nobody treats it as remarkable.

Section 956 of the American code sits underneath that practice, and almost nobody mentions it. It was written to stop profits being parked offshore and brought home informally.

A loan from a controlled foreign company to its own US shareholder counts as an investment in United States property. That can produce American income tax on money somebody only borrowed.

In our practice this arrives as a shock, because the British side has been handled perfectly. The company paid what it owed and the director fully intends to repay.

So the British treatment is half the picture, and the half nobody checked is the expensive one.

What is a director's loan?

A director's loan is money taken from the company that is not salary, not a dividend and not a repayment of expenses the director has already met. The GOV.UK guidance calls the running record of it a director's loan account.

An overdrawn account means the director owes the company. That direction creates all the problems.

What a section 956 inclusion actually is

Section 956 makes the shareholder include an amount measured by the property held, which the company's applicable earnings then cap.

That figure looks at what the company has banked over the years and what it made this year, ignoring loss years, and takes off whatever it has already paid out.

So a company with little in the way of earnings produces a small section 956 figure. A profitable company that has retained its profits produces a great deal.

That cap is the single most useful thing to know, because it tells you which companies are exposed and which are not.

Work the earnings figure out first, then worry about the loan. One number settles most cases.

Why section 956 reaches a British loan

Because a UK company owned by a US person is usually a controlled foreign company, and section 956 watches what it does with its money.

One of the things section 956 watches is lending to the shareholder. What a US person owes the company counts, for these purposes, as the company investing in American property. A director's loan is exactly that.

Standing behind the shareholder's own borrowing counts too. Pledge the company's assets, or guarantee the debt, and the company is treated as if it held the debt itself.

So the American system sees a director's loan perfectly well, even though it is a loan rather than a distribution.

Our note on owning a UK company as an American covers the wider position these rules sit inside.

What it costs on the British side

If the director does not repay within nine months of the end of the accounting period, the company pays Corporation Tax at 33.75% of the outstanding amount. The guidance sets out the mechanics.

Loans made before 6 April 2022 carry 32.5% instead, so older balances follow the older figure.

The outstanding balance at the period end goes on form CT600A with the Company Tax Return.

Interest runs on that Corporation Tax until somebody settles the tax or clears the loan.

So the nine-month deadline is the one that governs everything on this side. Everybody in a British company knows it, which is part of why the American rule goes unnoticed.

United KingdomUnited States
Charge on an unrepaid balance33.75% Corporation TaxPossible inclusion as US property
TriggerNine months after the period endThe loan itself, within the earnings cap
Does repayment fix itYes, the tax is reclaimableNo, the inclusion has already arisen
Threshold£10,000 for the benefit in kindNo equivalent threshold
Guarantee of personal borrowingNot the same chargeTreated as holding the obligation
Where it is reportedCT600A, and Self AssessmentThe shareholder's return and Form 5471

Getting the British charge back

The company reclaims the Corporation Tax once the loan goes, whether by repayment, write-off or release. It is a deposit rather than a permanent cost.

The claim ripens a day past the nine-month mark, counted from the close of whichever period saw the balance go, and nothing comes back before then.

Claims run to a four-year time limit, and no amount of the interest comes back.

Within two years of the end of the accounting period the claim goes on CT600A. After that, or for a different period, form L2P does the job.

The ten thousand pound line

Above £10,000 a director's loan also counts as a benefit in kind. The company deducts Class 1 National Insurance through payroll on it.

Where the company charges interest below the official rate, it records the discounted interest as its own income and treats it as a benefit.

The director reports the loan and any discounted interest on a Self Assessment return, and may owe Income Tax on it.

So one balance can produce a corporation tax charge, a National Insurance liability and a personal income tax entry at once.

The exception that does not help you

Section 956 carries an exception for obligations of a United States person, and reading it quickly gives false comfort.

It covers an American who is neither a US company nor a shareholder in the foreign one.

A shareholder-director is precisely the person it excludes. Lending to an unconnected American is outside the rule; lending to the owner is the target of it.

So the section 956 exception confirms the trap rather than relieving it.

An illustrative example

Take an American in Manchester who owns her UK consultancy outright and draws £60,000 from it during the year, recorded as a loan.

Her accountant tells her to clear the director's loan within nine months of the year end, which she plans to do, so no Corporation Tax charge arises.

The company has several years of retained profits. On her American return the loan can count as an investment in United States property, with those earnings capping the inclusion.

She has borrowed her own money, intends to repay it, and may owe American tax before she does.

Is it even a loan for American purposes?

Is it even a loan for American purposes? — section 956
From our guide to Section 956 and a UK director's loan.

That question comes first and it matters enormously, because an advance that nobody ever intended to repay never was a director's loan. The American analysis looks for a genuine obligation, which means a real expectation of repayment rather than a bookkeeping entry made at the year end.

Where that is missing, the advance can turn into something else, usually a distribution or compensation.

Both of those carry their own consequences, and neither one is automatically worse.

So the paperwork matters. A written agreement, a rate of interest and actual repayments all help.

What a clean arrangement looks like

A written loan agreement with a repayment date. Interest at a commercial rate, charged in fact and paid in fact.

Repayments landing on the dates the agreement names, rather than one clearing entry before the deadline.

A borrower who could plausibly repay from their own resources if asked.

So handle it the way you would handle a loan to a stranger. That is close to what both systems are testing for.

The reporting that follows

The company already appears on an American information return for the shareholder. Our note on Form 5471 covers that filing.

The form and its instructions carry the schedules where this sort of thing is reported.

An inclusion of this kind has to reach the return rather than sit in the company's books alone.

So a director's loan is a filing event as well as a tax event, and the two separate by accident very easily.

Better ways to take the money

Salary, which the company deducts and both systems tax in the ordinary way.

Dividends, which have their own rate structure and their own treaty treatment. Our note on salary or dividends covers the comparison.

Repayment of a genuine loan the director previously made to the company, which is simply the account running the other way.

So the usual answer is to choose a route deliberately rather than letting a balance accumulate and dealing with it in month nine.

Which companies are actually exposed

Ones with retained profits. The inclusion cannot exceed the company's applicable earnings, so the earnings figure decides the size of the problem.

A young company that has distributed everything it made has little to include. A mature one that has banked profits for years has a lot.

The loan balance matters too, but only up to that cap.

So pull the earnings figure before anything else. It often ends the enquiry in ten minutes.

What to do if a balance already exists

Do not panic and clear it in a rush. A sudden repayment followed by a fresh advance looks exactly like what it is.

Work out the company's earnings and the dates the balance was outstanding.

Document the arrangement properly from here, even if the early months were informal.

Then decide how to take money out in future, and stop the balance rebuilding.

  1. Establish the company's accumulated and current earnings.
  2. List every advance and repayment with its date.
  3. Check whether the arrangement looks like a genuine loan on the American test.
  4. Put a written agreement, an interest rate and a repayment schedule in place.
  5. Work out whether a section 956 inclusion arises, capped by those earnings.
  6. Report it on the shareholder's return alongside the company's information return.
  7. Choose a route for future drawings and keep the balance at nil.

What your UK accountant is doing right

Watching the nine-month clock. Filing the CT600A. Charging interest where the balance crosses £10,000.

All of that is correct British practice and none of it is the problem.

The gap is section 956, a rule in another country with no British equivalent and no reason to appear on their radar.

So the fix is not a new accountant. It is a second pair of eyes on the American side of the same facts.

Send them this article if it helps. The British treatment stands; only the second computation is missing.

Common mistakes we see

The first is assuming the nine-month repayment solves everything. It solves the British charge and leaves section 956 untouched.

The second is treating a guarantee as safe. A company guaranteeing the shareholder's borrowing holds the obligation for this purpose.

The third is relying on the section 956 exception for obligations of a United States person without reading who it excludes.

A fourth is recording it only in the accounts, with no agreement, no interest and no schedule.

How we help with a company balance

We start with the company's earnings, because that figure caps the exposure and often settles the question quickly.

Then we look at whether the advance is a genuine loan on the American test, since that decides whether section 956 is even the right question.

Our US federal returns work covers the inclusion and the schedules behind it, and you can get in touch before the year end rather than after it.

So the useful moment is while the balance is still small. By month nine the options have narrowed to repayment.

Last reviewed . Tax thresholds and rates change annually — check the figures against the current tax year.

Questions this raises for readers

On the British side, largely yes, because clearing a director's loan within nine months of the accounting period end avoids the 33.75% charge. Section 956 is separate and repayment does not undo it, so somebody with a US passport needs both questions answered rather than one.


It works as a deposit rather than a permanent charge. The company pays it where a director's loan still stands nine months after the period end, and reclaims it once that balance goes. The interest that accrued in the meantime cannot be reclaimed, so delay has a real cost.


The £10,000 line matters for the benefit in kind, the National Insurance and the personal reporting. Section 956 has no equivalent threshold, but the company's earnings cap the inclusion, so a company with few retained profits produces little exposure.


That lands the same way. Where the company pledges assets behind the shareholder's borrowing, or guarantees it, the rules treat the company as holding that debt, so a guarantee can produce the same result as a direct loan without any money leaving the company.


Charging a commercial rate and paying it helps establish a genuine director's loan, which is a different and prior question. It does not by itself take the obligation outside section 956, so treat it as necessary rather than sufficient.


Because it is not a British rule and there is no reason a UK accountant would know it. The British treatment they are applying is correct. What is missing is the second computation, which only arises because the shareholder holds an American passport.


Often that is cleaner, because a dividend is a known quantity on both returns rather than a balance somebody has to defend. The comparison depends on rates, on the company's profits and on what else is on your returns, so it is worth modelling rather than assuming.

Money out of your own UK company?

We check the company's earnings, test whether the advance is a genuine loan on the American rules, and set up a route that works on both returns. This article is general information, not personal tax advice.

Get a fee quote