Skip to content
Get a fee quote
Cross-border·US UK Tax Hub Tax Team

A partner on one return and an employee on the other

Two coastlines facing each other across a narrow strait, illustrating LLP members, salaried status and US tax
Three statutory conditions decide whether an LLP member is really a partner for UK tax. An American member can fail them here and still be a partner there.

Becoming a partner in a British firm used to settle the tax question. You were self-employed, you filed a return, and the firm did not run you through payroll.

The salaried member rules changed that for limited liability partnerships. An LLP member with a fixed share and no real say can be taxed as an employee here.

An American LLP member in the same firm gets a complication nobody designed. The United States has its own view of what the firm is and what the member received.

In our practice this shows up as a credit that will not reconcile. Two countries are taxing different things with the same money.

So the first question is not the rate. It is what each system thinks the member is.

What is a salaried member?

A salaried member is an LLP member whom the UK rules treat as an employee for tax purposes. The label of partner does not survive the test. The HMRC guidance is explicit that only an individual who satisfies all three conditions falls into the category.

Section 863A of ITTOIA 2005 is the statutory home of the rules. They also need reading with the anti-avoidance provision that follows.

The three conditions

All three have to be met before the rules bite. Failing any one of them keeps the LLP member outside the regime.

That structure is why capital contributions attract so much attention in British firms. Condition C is the one a member can most readily change.

The test applies at a point in time rather than once and for all.

An LLP member is therefore brought inside by arithmetic rather than by seniority.

ConditionWhat it asksHow it fails
AIs at least 80% of the reward disguised salary?Reward that genuinely varies with firm profits
BDoes the member have significant influence over the affairs of the partnership?Real influence over the firm as a whole
CIs the contribution less than 25% of the expected disguised salary?Capital at or above the 25% line

Condition A and disguised salary

Condition A turns on a single proportion. It asks whether at least 80% of the total amount payable for the member's services will be disguised salary.

Disguised salary covers three things. A fixed amount counts. So does an amount that varies without reference to the overall profits or losses of the LLP, and so does one that in practice those profits never touch.

A profit share that moves with the firm's results is not disguised salary. That is the whole point of the test.

So the drafting of the remuneration arrangement decides this condition, not the label on the member's business card.

Condition B and significant influence

Condition B looks at the mutual rights and duties of the members. It is met where those rights do not give the LLP member significant influence over the affairs of the partnership.

Two words do the work. One is affairs, which means the partnership as a whole rather than a department, a team or a practice area.

The other is significant, which asks for influence with real commercial substance rather than control.

So the LLP agreement is the first document to read, and often the last word.

Rights to take part in high-level or strategic decisions are the likely home of significant influence. Day-to-day operational decisions are a far weaker case.

What the Supreme Court settled in 2026

Condition B reached the Supreme Court in HMRC v BlueCrest Capital Management (UK) LLP [2026] UKSC 18, decided on 1 July 2026. The court dismissed the appeal unanimously.

The holding is that significant influence has to come from the members' legally enforceable rights and duties under the LLP agreement. Influence that flows from strong performance, personal standing or relationships does not count.

The court also held that responsibility for high-value day-to-day investment decisions is not, by itself, significant influence.

Condition B went back to the First-tier Tribunal to be applied properly, so the facts of that case are not finished.

What that means for an LLP member now

Read the agreement rather than the organisation chart. Seniority and revenue do not answer Condition B.

Firms that relied on informal influence have a weaker position than they thought, particularly in investment management.

Firms whose agreements give members real rights over strategy are in a stronger one.

So the drafting of the LLP agreement is now the centre of this question rather than a background document.

Condition C and the 25% line

Condition C compares two numbers. It is met where the member's contribution to the LLP falls below 25% of the disguised salary expected for the tax year.

Contribution has its own statutory meaning and is not simply whatever the accounts call capital.

A member who puts in enough capital falls outside the rules. That is why firms ask new partners to contribute.

So test the ratio, and test it against the reward you expect rather than last year's.

Borrowing the money to contribute it is common. It does not stop the contribution counting, though the loan has its own consequences on both returns.

What happens when all three are met

Income tax then treats the member as employed by the LLP under a contract of service. Their rights and duties as a member count as rights and duties under that contract.

In practice that means PAYE, employee National Insurance and an employer charge for the firm.

It does not make the individual an employee for every other purpose, which is a distinction that confuses people regularly.

So the tax treatment changes while the legal relationship stays what the LLP agreement says it is.

Why firms set it up this way

Partly to give junior members a predictable income, which is a reasonable commercial aim rather than a tax one.

Partly because capital contributions are hard to ask of somebody in their first year.

The rules were written on the view that an arrangement which looks like employment should be taxed as employment.

So the regime and the business reason for the arrangement point in the same direction, which is why the position is stable rather than contested.

None of that makes salaried member status a failure. It is a tax characterisation, and plenty of successful partners spend years inside it.

Why an American member has a second problem

Why an American member has a second problem — LLP member
From our guide to LLP members, salaried status and US tax.

Because the American analysis starts somewhere else entirely. It asks what the LLP is for US purposes, and then what the LLP member received from it.

The classification of a foreign entity never settles itself. Form 8832 carries the election where a firm wants one.

Nothing in that analysis turns on whether HMRC has recharacterised the member as an employee.

So one person can be an employee in one system and a partner in the other. Same work, same year, two answers.

Ask the firm what election, if any, it has made. An LLP member rarely knows, and the answer changes every figure on the American side.

An illustrative example

Take an American LLP member at a London law firm. She receives a fixed £180,000 with a small discretionary element, and she holds no capital.

The British answer is PAYE on the whole amount. National Insurance follows on both sides, with a payroll entry each month.

The American answer depends on the firm's classification and on her interest in it. It may well be a share of partnership income rather than wages.

One receipt, two characters, and a foreign tax credit that has to bridge the gap.

Give her a 10% capital contribution instead and nothing changes, because the line is 25%. Take her onto the management board and the answer can change entirely.

Does the credit still work?

Usually it does something. The real question is how much of the British tax finds a home on the American return. A credit needs the same income, taxed by both countries in the same year, and a difference of character makes that matching harder rather than impossible.

The amounts are typically large enough that a partial failure is expensive.

So the computation deserves attention rather than an assumption that it nets off.

A salaried member paying PAYE has British tax deducted monthly, which at least makes the amount easy to evidence.

National Insurance and self-employment tax

A salaried member pays employee National Insurance under PAYE, while a genuine partner pays Class 4 instead. The American system has its own parallel in self-employment tax.

The totalisation agreement decides which country's social security system a cross-border worker belongs in. A certificate of coverage is the evidence of it.

The firm's payroll handles the British side without the member doing anything. The American side needs somebody to decide whether a liability arises there at all, and that decision rests on the certificate rather than on the payslip.

Our notes on the totalisation agreement and on self-employment tax across the two systems cover how that works in practice.

So settle the social security question separately, because it does not follow the income tax answer.

What to check when you are made up

Promotion to the partnership is the moment to look at all of this. Documents signed on day one settle most of it.

A member who understands which condition they fail can at least predict the treatment.

So read the agreement as a tax document as well as a commercial one.

Nobody at the firm will volunteer the salaried member analysis, because for British purposes it is settled and uncontroversial.

  1. Read the LLP agreement, particularly the clauses on profit share and on decision-making.
  2. Work out what proportion of your expected reward varies with the firm's overall results.
  3. Ask what capital contribution is expected and when it has to be paid.
  4. Compare that contribution with 25% of the expected fixed element.
  5. Ask whether you sit on anything that gives influence over the firm rather than your team.
  6. Tell your US adviser before the arrangement is signed rather than after the first payslip.
  7. Keep the agreement and the capital account statements with your tax papers.

If the position changes mid-year

A change in the facts means a fresh test. A capital contribution or a new role can move somebody out of the regime partway through a year.

That produces a split year on the British side with two kinds of income in it.

The American return still reports the year as a whole, on its own characterisation.

So keep a note of the date things changed, because it will matter to both computations.

Moving between the two states

An LLP member who becomes a full equity partner usually leaves the regime, and the payslip shows it immediately.

The American side may show no change at all, because nothing in its analysis moved.

That asymmetry is worth flagging to whoever prepares the US return, since the British paperwork looks dramatic and the American answer may not be.

So explain the change rather than sending the documents and hoping.

Keep the dates. A year that starts in salaried member status and ends outside it needs both halves documented.

Common mistakes we see

The first is assuming the title of partner settles the tax question. It has not settled it since the rules arrived.

The second is treating Condition B as satisfied because the member runs a large team. The test looks at the partnership.

The third is contributing capital without checking the ratio against the expected reward for the year ahead.

A fourth is reporting the British position on the American return without asking what the firm is for US purposes.

A fifth is assuming salaried member status is permanent once it applies. The conditions get retested whenever the facts move.

How we help with LLP membership

We read the LLP agreement first. Documents answer the three conditions; impressions do not.

Then we work out what the American return should show, and how much of the British tax it can absorb.

Our US federal returns work covers that. You can get in touch before accepting the terms of a partnership.

So the cheapest moment is while the agreement is still a draft.

Last reviewed . Tax thresholds and rates change annually — check the figures against the current tax year.

Questions this raises for readers

Yes. HMRC's guidance states that only an individual who satisfies all three conditions is a salaried member, so failing any one of them keeps the member outside the rules. That is why firms concentrate on the condition that is easiest to fail deliberately, which is usually the capital contribution test.


A fixed amount, an amount that varies without reference to the LLP's overall profits or losses, or an amount that in practice is not affected by them. A genuine profit share that rises and falls with the firm's results is not disguised salary, which is what takes a member outside Condition A.


Condition C is met where the contribution is less than 25% of the disguised salary expected for the tax year, so a contribution at or above that level fails the condition and takes the member out. Contribution has a statutory meaning of its own, so check it rather than reading the capital account.


No. The American analysis asks what the entity is for US purposes and what the member received from it, and nothing in that turns on how HMRC has characterised the arrangement. The result is that the same money can be employment income in one system and partnership income in the other.


No. The test asks about influence over the affairs of the partnership as a whole, and the Supreme Court held in 2026 that the influence must come from the members' legally enforceable rights and duties under the LLP agreement. Informal influence from performance or standing does not count, and nor does responsibility for high-value investment decisions by itself.


A salaried member pays employee National Insurance through PAYE and the firm pays the employer charge, where a genuine partner would pay Class 4 instead. Which country's social security system applies at all is decided by the totalisation agreement, so that question should be answered separately.


They are aimed at limited liability partnerships, which is where the structural issue arises. A member of a general partnership is in a different position, though the broader question of what each country thinks the firm and the member are still needs answering for anybody with a US filing obligation.

Partner in a UK LLP with a US passport?

We read the LLP agreement against the three conditions, work out what the American return should show, and test how much of the British tax is creditable. This article is general information, not personal tax advice.

Get a fee quote