
Two founders sell the same company on the same day for the same price, and both claim Business Asset Disposal Relief. One is British and one is American, and only one of them keeps the saving.
The reason is the foreign tax credit. It relieves double taxation but never takes the American charge below what American rules impose, so every pound the British bill falls, the American one rises to meet it.
There is a sharper risk underneath that. A gain is foreign for credit purposes only where at least a tenth of it is actually paid in foreign tax, and reliefs push that figure down.
So a claim that cuts the effective British rate far enough can remove the credit as well as the tax it saved. In our practice that is the most expensive thing people discover late.
This piece covers what Business Asset Disposal Relief gives, and then what it costs somebody filing on both sides of the Atlantic.
What is Business Asset Disposal Relief?
Business Asset Disposal Relief gives a reduced rate of Capital Gains Tax on qualifying disposals of a business or of shares in your own trading company. The GOV.UK guidance sets out who qualifies and on what.
You claim it rather than receiving it automatically, and a lifetime limit caps the gains that can benefit.
The top-up problem
A credit relieves double taxation. It never takes the American charge below what the American rules impose.
So where the British tax on the gain falls short of the American tax on the same gain, the credit covers part of it and the balance falls due in the United States.
At the main British rate of 24% the foreign tax usually absorbs the American charge. At the relieved rate of 18% there may not be.
So the relief lowers the British bill and the American one rises to meet it. The saving moves rather than vanishing, which is not the same as keeping it.
| British founder | American founder | |
|---|---|---|
| UK rate with the relief | 18% | 18% |
| UK rate without it | 24% | 24% |
| US charge on the same gain | None | Long-term capital gain rates |
| Effect of claiming | Keeps the whole saving | Credit shrinks as UK tax falls |
| Extra US charge to budget for | None | Net investment income tax |
| Risk if the effective rate is very low | None | Gain may be US source, with no credit |
Why an American ends up somewhere else
Because the United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income and takes no notice of a British relief. The gain counts as a long-term capital gain there, on its own rules and at its own rates.
The IRS topic on capital gains sets out the American treatment. Relief for the overlap comes through the foreign tax credit rather than from anything the British return did.
The IRS guidance on the credit sets out how that relief works. It is a credit for tax actually paid, not a matching of rates.
So each country computes its charge independently, and only then do the two meet. That order is what people get wrong.
Our note on owning a UK company as an American covers the position during the years before a sale.
The rate, and the direction it has moved
From 6 April 2026 the qualifying rate is 18%. The rates page states it directly for sole traders, partnerships and trustees.
A higher or additional rate taxpayer pays 24% on gains that do not qualify. So the relief is worth six percentage points rather than the much larger gap it used to represent.
The rate has risen in stages and earlier disposals follow the rate for their own year, so check the date of disposal rather than the date on the completion paperwork.
So the relief is less valuable than it was, and for an American it was already worth less than the headline suggested.
Two GOV.UK pages currently disagree about the rate for the previous tax year, so anybody with a 2025-26 disposal should confirm the figure before filing rather than relying on a summary.
What you have to satisfy
For shares in your own company the conditions run for at least two years before the sale. You need to be an employee or office holder of the company or of one in its group.
The company needs to trade rather than invest, or to head a trading group.
It also has to count as your personal company: at least 5% of the shares and 5% of the voting rights, with an entitlement to at least 5% of distributable profits and winding-up assets or of the sale proceeds.
Shares from an enterprise management incentive follow a modified test, where the option predates the sale by at least two years.
Every one of those conditions has to hold throughout the period, not merely on the day of sale. A reorganisation in year one can break a claim in year three.
An illustrative example
Take an American in Bristol selling shares in the company she founded, with a qualifying gain after the annual exempt amount.
Claiming the relief, she pays 18% to HMRC. Without it she would hand over 24%.
On her American return the same gain meets the long-term rate, with credit for the British tax actually paid. The lower the British figure, the more of the American charge is left standing.
Her co-founder, who holds only a British passport, keeps the whole six points. She keeps rather less of them.
Where sourcing becomes the real risk
A credit only works where the income counts as foreign for American purposes, and a gain on shares does not become foreign merely because the company is British.
The general rule sources a gain on personal property by reference to the seller. A US citizen counts as a US resident for that purpose unless they have a tax home in a foreign country.
Even then there is a condition. The citizen counts as a non-resident for the sale only where an income tax of at least 10% of the gain actually reaches a foreign country.
So the sourcing that makes the credit possible depends on paying enough foreign tax, which is an uncomfortable thing to depend on when you have just claimed a relief.
- Establish whether your tax home is in the UK for the year of disposal.
- Compute the gain under British rules, after losses and the annual exempt amount.
- Work out the British tax actually payable on that gain.
- Express it as a percentage of the gain, not of anything else.
- Check it clears 10%, which is what makes the gain foreign source.
- Compute the American charge on the gain, including the investment income charge.
- Claim the credit, and consider the treaty provision where the credit still falls short.
Why a very low effective rate is dangerous
The 10% test looks at tax actually paid on that gain, not at a headline rate. Losses, the annual exempt amount and the relief itself all push the effective figure down.
A disposal bearing less than a tenth of the gain in British tax fails the test. The gain is then American source and the credit has nothing to attach to.
That is the worst outcome on the menu: a modest British bill and a full American one, with no relief between them.
So compute the effective rate before claiming anything. The headline rate is not the number the test uses.
Does the treaty rescue it?
The convention has a provision designed for exactly this kind of mismatch, which treats certain income as arising in the other country so that American relief can reach it. It offers a genuine fix rather than a theoretical one, which is why the position is rarely hopeless.
It does not operate automatically. Somebody has to identify the relief, compute it and claim it on the return.
The amount it reaches also stops at what the double charge requires rather than running open-ended.
So take advice on the specific disposal. This is a provision that rewards being read properly.
The extra American charge nobody budgets for
A gain of this size often brings the net investment income tax with it, which is a separate charge on top of the capital gains rate.
Whether foreign tax reaches that charge is contested ground, and our note on the net investment income tax abroad covers where that stands.
Budget for it either way. Assuming relief arrives is an expensive thing to build a number on.
So model the total American charge rather than the headline capital gains rate alone.
What a holiday let business lost
One group lost access to Business Asset Disposal Relief entirely. Furnished holiday lettings stopped qualifying for disposals on or after 6 April 2025.
Where such a business ceased before that date, relief can still reach a disposal within the normal three-year period after cessation.
That is a narrow saving and it is running out. Anybody in that position should be looking at dates rather than at rates.
So check which regime the business was in before assuming the relief is available at all.
Timing a sale across two tax years
The British tax year ends on 5 April and the American one on 31 December, so a single disposal falls into two differently dated years.
That matters for the credit, because it follows the year the foreign tax is paid rather than the year the gain arose for American purposes.
A December completion and an April payment can therefore sit in different American years, which complicates the relief.
So look at the payment dates as well as the completion date. Our note on the credit carryover covers what happens to amounts that do not land.
Payments on account and instalments complicate it further. The credit follows the money, not the assessment.
What this does not change
The relief does not alter what you owe in the United States. It alters what you owe here.
It does not change the date the gain arises either, on either side.
And it does not remove the reporting. The disposal goes on both returns whatever rate applies.
So treat it as a rate decision with a knock-on effect, not as a planning structure.
Common mistakes we see
The first is treating the British computation as the answer. It is half of one.
The second is claiming Business Asset Disposal Relief reflexively, along with everything else on offer. A relief that drops the effective rate below the sourcing threshold can cost more than it saves.
The third is leaving the American side until the return falls due. By then the deal has already taken its shape.
A fourth is forgetting the separate investment income charge, which is not part of the headline rate anybody quotes.
How we help with a company sale
We model both charges together before anything is signed, because the comparison is meaningless one country at a time.
Then we test the effective British rate against the sourcing threshold, which is the step most likely to be missed.
Our treaty relief work covers the credit and the provisions behind it, and you can get in touch while the deal is still being structured.
So the useful moment is months before completion. Afterwards the arithmetic is what it is.




