
A fund manager's carry has always sat awkwardly between two ideas. It looks like a return on an investment and it behaves like a reward for work.
Britain resolved that argument in April 2026 by putting carried interest inside the income tax system. The policy paper is blunt about it.
The United States resolved the same argument differently and much earlier, by keeping the capital gain label and attaching a holding period to it.
In our practice the people caught between those two answers are US citizens working in London funds, and they rarely find out until somebody prepares the second return.
The rate matters less than the mismatch. One country is taxing earned income and the other is taxing a gain.
What is carried interest?
Carried interest is the share of a fund's profits that goes to the people managing it, usually once investors have had their capital back and a preferred return. It is the manager's main economic reward and it is not a salary.
The argument about how to tax it has run for decades in both countries.
Both countries agree it is valuable. They have never agreed on what it is.
What changed in Britain
The revised regime has effect on and after 6 April 2026, and it sits wholly within the Income Tax framework.
Carried interest is now treated as trading profits and charged to Income Tax and Class 4 National Insurance contributions.
The capital gains guidance now lists carried interest received from that date among the things you do not pay Capital Gains Tax on.
So the charge did not simply get bigger. It moved house.
Class 4 National Insurance is the part people overlook, because a capital gain never carried a social charge at all.
The 72.5% multiplier
Where carried interest qualifies, the amount treated as trading profits is 72.5% of the qualifying profits.
Qualifying profits means the qualifying carried interest less the permitted deductions that apply to it.
The multiplier exists because the reward is not quite ordinary employment income and the regime acknowledges that.
So the headline income tax rate bites on a reduced slice rather than on the whole receipt.
Permitted deductions matter here too, since they come off before the multiplier applies rather than after it.
What makes carry qualify
The qualifying amount depends on the average holding period of the relevant investment scheme. Funds that hold investments for longer get a better answer.
That is a feature the previous rules also had, so the concept is familiar even though the framework around it is new.
The arithmetic happens at the level of the scheme rather than the individual, so the manager's own tax position depends on how the fund behaved.
So ask the fund for its holding period computation rather than estimating it.
Funds with a short average holding period get a worse answer, which is the policy working as intended rather than an accident of drafting.
What the United States does instead
The American answer keeps the capital gain label and attaches a holding period to it. The IRS guidance on section 1061 sets out how that works.
Gain allocated through an applicable partnership interest counts as long-term only where the asset was held for more than three years.
Gain that fails the test turns short-term, which attracts ordinary rates without ever becoming ordinary income.
So both countries have a holding period test and neither one matches the other.
Note the asymmetry in what each test measures. Britain looks at the scheme as a whole, while America looks at the individual asset behind the allocated gain.
| UK from 6 April 2026 | US | |
|---|---|---|
| Character | Trading profits | Capital gain |
| Tax charged | Income Tax | Capital gains tax |
| Social charge | Class 4 National Insurance | None on a capital gain |
| Holding period test | Average holding period of the scheme | More than three years for the asset |
| Amount brought in | 72.5% of qualifying profits | The allocated gain in full |
Why the mismatch costs money
Because a foreign tax credit needs the same income, in the same year, in the same category. A character difference puts pressure on all three.
Britain is now charging Income Tax on trading profits. America is charging tax on a capital gain allocated from a partnership.
The Form 1116 instructions show how the income categories work, and getting the category wrong is how credits go unused.
So the exposure is not the headline rate in either country. It is the part of the British tax that matches nothing on the other return.
Is the rate really the point?
Not usually, and that is the most useful thing to understand about the new regime. Two countries can both charge a sensible rate and still leave a manager paying more than either rate alone implies, simply because the credit will not stretch across a character difference.
The exposure lives in the gap rather than in either column.
So model the combined position rather than comparing headline rates.
Then the planning questions become obvious rather than abstract.
An illustrative example
Take an American partner in a London fund who receives £1 million of qualifying carried interest in a year, with the scheme's holding period comfortably long.
In Britain, 72.5% of the qualifying profits is treated as trading profits and charged to Income Tax, with Class 4 National Insurance on top.
In America the same receipt is an allocation of gain from the fund, tested against the three-year rule and taxed as a capital gain.
She has one economic reward, two computations and a real risk that the credit does not line up cleanly.
Change one fact and the picture moves. A scheme with a shorter average holding period gives her a worse British answer, while assets held under three years give her a worse American one.
Does National Insurance get credit?
Class 4 National Insurance is a social security contribution rather than an income tax, and the two systems treat those separately. The totalisation agreement between the countries deals with social security, while the income tax treaty deals with income tax.
So the Class 4 charge is not automatically creditable against an American income tax bill.
Our note on the totalisation agreement covers which country's system a cross-border worker belongs in.
Get that question settled first, because it decides whether the Class 4 charge should arise at all.
Timing is the other mismatch
The two regimes do not necessarily bring the reward into charge in the same tax year, and the tax years themselves do not align.
A credit generally needs the foreign tax to relate to income taxed in the same year, so a timing gap can strand it.
Carryback and carryforward help, though they are a repair rather than a plan.
So model the year of the charge in both countries before the distribution rather than afterwards.
Our note on UK capital gains on shares covers the ordinary case that carry no longer sits inside.
Reporting the American side
A partnership with applicable partnership interests has to attach a worksheet to each holder's Schedule K-1 and report it in box 20 of Form 1065.
That worksheet is the raw material for the three-year test, so chase it if it does not arrive.
So the American filing depends on information only the fund has.
Keep the worksheet even in a year with no distribution, because the holding period history matters later.
- Get the fund's Schedule K-1 and find the box 20 disclosure for applicable partnership interests.
- Read the attached worksheet, which carries the figures the three-year test needs.
- Separate the gain that meets the holding period from the gain that does not.
- Convert the British tax paid, and identify which income category it belongs to.
- Check whether any of it is creditable against the same income in the same year.
- Keep the fund's average holding period computation with the return papers.
Does leaving the UK solve it?
Not by itself, because American citizenship travels with you and the carry usually relates to work done while you were in Britain. A move changes the British position and leaves the American one broadly where it was, so the mismatch this article describes survives the flight.
There are also rules dealing with people who leave and return, which exist precisely to stop a short absence resetting the charge.
Our note on the exit tax and covered expatriate status covers the more drastic version of the same question.
So treat relocation as a planning input, not as an answer.
What fund documents should say
They should say plainly what the carry is, when it vests and when it pays out.
Vagueness about timing is tolerable in one system and expensive across two.
A co-investment alongside the carry is a different thing again, and keeping the two apart in the paperwork makes both easier to report.
So read the partnership deed with the second return in mind.
What this means for the firm, not just the individual
A manager's tax position is now partly a function of how the fund is run, because the holding period belongs to the scheme.
That gives the firm a reporting duty it may not have had in quite this form before.
American partners add a second layer, since the fund has to produce the figures their returns depend on.
So the administration team is part of the answer here, not a bystander.
Records to keep from the first year
The partnership deed and any side letter that touches the carry. Those documents decide what everything else means.
Then the fund's holding period computation for each year, with the workings rather than just the conclusion.
Then the British tax actually paid, split between Income Tax and Class 4 National Insurance, because the two travel differently.
Finally the Schedule K-1 and its worksheet, filed with the year they relate to.
Six years of these papers is not excessive. A question about a 2026 distribution can arrive a long time after the fund has moved on.
Common mistakes we see
The first is assuming the British change simply raised the rate. It changed the character, which is a different problem.
The second is treating the two holding period tests as one. They measure different things over different periods.
The third is leaving the Class 4 National Insurance out of the planning entirely.
A fourth is filing the American return without the fund's worksheet, then amending when it arrives.
A fifth is waiting for the fund to raise it. The fund files its own returns and has no reason to think about a partner's second country.
How we help with fund rewards
We start with the fund documents and the holding period computation, because those decide what both countries are taxing.
Then we build the credit position properly, including which British tax belongs in which American category.
Our treaty relief work covers that, and you can get in touch before a distribution rather than after it.
So the useful conversation happens in the year the carry crystallises, not the following spring.




