
Secondments rarely arrive with a tidy end date. Eighteen months becomes two years, then somebody mentions a permanent role.
Both tax systems help with the cost of getting to a posting and staying there. Detached duty relief is the British version, and America has its own.
They reach that point at different times. Britain looks at 24 months, America at twelve.
In our practice a conversation does the damage rather than a contract, because the relief turns on what everyone expects rather than on what happens.
So the date somebody said out loud that the job was becoming permanent is a tax fact worth recording.
What is detached duty relief?
Detached duty relief is the relief for travelling to a temporary workplace, meaning somewhere you attend for a task of limited duration or some other short-lived purpose. HMRC's booklet 490 sets out the test in chapter 3, separating a posting with an end in sight from a place you simply work.
Travel to a temporary workplace attracts relief. Travel to a permanent one is ordinary commuting, which gets nothing.
Why the rules exist at all
Ordinary commuting is a private cost, and both systems are clear that getting to work is your own affair.
A posting away from your normal base differs, because the travel exists only for the employer's purposes.
The time limits are there to stop a temporary workplace quietly becoming a normal one with relief attached.
So each rule asks the same question: when did the posting stop being an interruption and start being the job?
Neither country is trying to catch you out here. Both are drawing a line somewhere, and they drew it in different places.
The 24-month rule
A workplace stops being temporary where the employee attends it in a period of continuous work lasting, or likely to last, more than 24 months.
That is the half of detached duty relief people quote, and they usually stop there.
The other half is a 40% test, and both parts must be met before a workplace counts as permanent.
So the two conditions work together, and failing either one keeps detached duty relief alive.
A temporary workplace that outlasts the expectation therefore loses the label.
The 40% test nobody mentions
Duties count as performed to a significant extent where someone spends at least 40% of their working time there.
HMRC's own example runs a site attended for under 40% of working time across more than 24 months, and it stays temporary throughout.
So somebody splitting their week between two offices may keep the relief indefinitely.
Do the arithmetic rather than assuming, because the answer often surprises people.
So a temporary workplace can stay temporary for years where the time split is right.
| Time at the site | Expected duration | Still temporary? |
|---|---|---|
| 40% or more of working time | More than 24 months | No |
| 40% or more of working time | 24 months or less | Yes |
| Under 40% of working time | More than 24 months | Yes |
| Under 40% of working time | Any duration | Yes |
Expectation beats reality
This is the trap, in both countries, and it catches careful people.
Where circumstances change so that attendance will exceed 24 months, the workplace stops being temporary from the date the expectation changed.
It does not wait for the 24 months to elapse, and it does not wait for a new contract.
So a secondment extended in month nine loses detached duty relief from month nine, not month twenty-five.
A posting that ends early
Relief is not clawed back where a posting genuinely expected to run three years ends after eighteen months.
The test looks at what you reasonably expected at the time, not at what happened.
That cuts both ways, which is why the contemporaneous evidence matters so much.
So keep the letter that set out the original plan, even once the plan has changed.
Diarise a review at each anniversary. The facts move even when the paperwork does not.
The fixed-term rule as well
A separate rule catches employments with a known end.
A workplace fails the test where someone attends it for at least 40% of their working time across more than 80% of the likely duration of the employment.
That matters for a two-year contract to work at one site, which can fail the test from day one.
So check the length of the employment, not only the length of the posting.
What counts as one period of work
The 24 months look at a continuous period of work rather than at a single contract.
A short break, or a move to a site down the road, does not necessarily start a fresh clock.
HMRC looks at whether the work and the place have genuinely changed.
So a nominal gap between two postings at the same office rarely achieves anything.
A genuine change of role at the same address can still restart it, but the change has to be real rather than cosmetic.
What America does instead
It relieves travel for a temporary assignment and refuses it for an indefinite one. Topic 511 puts the line at a year.
Any work assignment in excess of one year counts as indefinite, and the expenses stop being deductible.
The expectation rule appears here too: where a realistic expectation of more than a year arises, the costs become non-deductible from the point the expectation changes.
So the two systems share a structure and disagree about the number.
The window where they disagree
Between twelve and twenty-four months, a posting can be temporary in Britain and indefinite in America.
Relief for the same accommodation and the same flights can therefore apply on one return and not the other.
That is not an error in either computation. It is two rules with two thresholds.
So an eighteen-month secondment is the shape most likely to produce a surprise.
Detached duty relief and the American deduction are simply not the same concept wearing two names.
Coming the other way
The same rules apply to a Briton posted to the United States, with the countries swapped.
Their British relief runs on the 24-month test while the American side applies its one-year line to the same trip.
The mismatch is symmetrical, and so is the planning.
So an employer moving people in both directions has one problem rather than two.
An employer with people moving in both directions should set one policy rather than two, and apply it to whichever leg of the journey each person is on.
An illustrative example
Take an American sent to a London office on an eighteen-month secondment, with a flat paid for by the employer.
In Britain the workplace stays temporary throughout, so relief covers the accommodation and the travel.
In America the assignment exceeds a year from the outset, so it is indefinite and those costs are not deductible.
One posting, one set of receipts, two different answers.
Does the employer paying change it?
It changes who ends up out of pocket rather than whether relief exists, and it matters a great deal for how the money is taxed. Where a cost qualifies, an employer can meet it without creating a taxable benefit. Where it does not, the same payment counts as pay and goes through payroll.
So the question is not only whether you could deduct it, but whether the employer can reimburse it cleanly.
A relocation package built on the wrong assumption lands as taxable earnings on somebody's payslip.
What actually qualifies
Travel between home and the temporary workplace, which ordinary commuting never gets.
Accommodation and subsistence while working there, within the ordinary rules on what is reasonable.
The GOV.UK guidance for employees covers claiming where the employer has not paid.
So detached duty relief covers the cost of being away rather than the cost of living generally.
Keeping the evidence
The expectation evidence is the part nobody keeps, and the part that decides the answer.
An email saying the role might become permanent is worth more here than a year of receipts.
So file those messages where you can find them again.
- Record the start date of the posting and the end date everybody expected at the time.
- Keep the secondment letter, since it states the expectation in writing.
- Note the date of any conversation or email that changed that expectation.
- Track the proportion of working time spent at each workplace across the period.
- Keep receipts for travel, accommodation and subsistence, separated by workplace.
- Record what the employer reimbursed and what you paid yourself.
- Convert the figures for the American return on a consistent method.
Where the American side bites hardest
Publication 463 sets out the wider rules on travel and what being away from home means.
The concept of a tax home does a lot of work there, and it is not simply where you live.
Somebody who moves their family and gives up the old home may find their tax home has moved with them.
So the analysis starts with where the tax home is, before anything about duration.
Get that settled before arguing about months, because a moved tax home ends the argument.
How this sits with the rest of a posting
Relocation payments, housing allowances and school fees all have their own treatment on each side.
Our notes on relocation packages and on remote work for a US employer cover the surrounding position.
Payroll in one country and a tax return in the other is the normal state of affairs for a secondee.
So treat travel relief as one line in a wider package rather than a standalone question.
Two payrolls, one set of costs
A secondee frequently stays on a home payroll while working abroad, or runs a shadow payroll in the host country.
Travel and accommodation can show up in one system and stay invisible in the other.
That makes reconciling the two returns harder than the underlying rules suggest.
So ask for the payroll reports from both countries rather than working from payslips alone.
Our note on reading a P60 for a US return covers what the British paperwork does and does not show.
Common mistakes we see
The first is quoting the 24-month rule without the 40% test, and giving up detached duty relief that was still available.
The second is waiting until month 24 to stop claiming, when the expectation changed much earlier.
The third is assuming the British answer carries across, when America stops at a year.
A fourth is losing the secondment letter, which is the only contemporaneous record of what anyone expected.
A fifth is treating a temporary workplace as a question about the building. It is a question about the job you are there to do.
How we help with a secondment
We establish the expected duration and the working time split first, because those two facts decide most of detached duty relief.
Then we work out what each country relieves, and what the employer can reimburse without creating taxable pay.
Our US federal returns work covers the American side, and you can get in touch at the start of a posting rather than the end.
So the position is set up correctly while the paperwork still reflects what people expected.




